Skip to content
Not Class Time

Track C: reinforcement, not the main event

Your board has to let you speak. It cannot give you lunch.

Both halves of that matter. New Jersey law guarantees you a public comment period at every board of education meeting. That is a real, enforceable right that most people do not know they have. And your board still cannot lawfully allow phones at lunch, so what you ask it for has to be something it can actually do.

District decision

Ask for the right thing

Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent a board of education from adopting a policy … that is more stringent than the guidelines developed by the commissioner…s.2.e

There is no matching clause letting it adopt a looser one. So “please allow phones at lunch” is a request your board must refuse whatever it thinks of the merits.

What it can do is pass a resolution urging the Commissioner to revise the state guidance, and take your input into the annual policy review the guidance itself asks districts to run.Communicating Policy

What the law actually gives you

One statute, four things it hands you

  • Public comment is required at every meeting

    This is the strongest thing on this page and it is easy to miss. The Open Public Meetings Act does not permit a comment period; it requires one, at every meeting, and the wording is beside this list. The board decides how long that portion is. It does not get to decide whether to have one.10:4-12(a)

  • The subject is yours to choose, not theirs

    The statutory scope is any issue a member of the public feels may be of concern to district residents. NJSBA tells its own member boards that they cannot prohibit comment based on subject matter within that scope. A device policy the whole district is living under is plainly inside it.source

  • You get at least 48 hours' notice

    “Adequate notice” means written advance notice of at least 48 hours giving the time, date, location and, to the extent known, the agenda. Every board must also post an annual schedule of its regular meetings, by 10 January at the latest.10:4-8(d)10:4-18

  • You can ask to be mailed the notices

    Any person may request that the board mail them the meeting schedule and the advance notices, on prepayment of a reasonable fee if the board has set one. The request expires at midnight on 31 December each year, so it has to be renewed.10:4-19

  • Minutes are public

    Every board must keep minutes showing who was there, what was considered, what was done and how each member voted, and make them promptly available. If you spoke and want a record of it, the minutes are where to look.10:4-14

Open_Public_Meetings_Act.pdfN.J.S.A. 10:4-12(a)
… a board of education shall be required to set aside a portion of every meeting… the length of the portion to be determined by the … board of education, for public comment on any governmental or school district issue that a member of the public feels may be of concern to the residents of the municipality or school district.

One correction worth making, because it is repeated everywhere: the board-of-education comment requirement was not in the original 1975 Act. It was added in 2008: the 2002 amendment covered municipal governing bodies only.L.1975 c.231 s.7, amended 2008 c.14

What a board may lawfully restrict

The New Jersey Supreme Court settled this in 2010: the public comment period of a school board meeting is a public forumsource. That is a strong protection, but a forum with rules. A board may impose reasonable time, place and manner restrictions so long as they are content-neutral.

What it may not do is pick and choose by viewpoint. Once the floor is open, a board may not grant the use of a forum to people whose views it finds acceptable, but deny use to those wishing to express less favored or more controversial viewssource, and if it restricts speech, the board carries the burden of showing a permissible reason.

  • A time limit per speaker, and a limit on the whole comment period. Both are lawful. Three minutes and five minutes are both common.
  • A sign-in sheet, and a requirement that you state your name and where you live before speaking. Most district bylaws we read ask for a municipality rather than a street address.
  • Stopping a speaker who is disruptive, off the subject, or repeating what has already been said. Besler expressly permits this.
  • Rules of decorum, and removing somebody who will not stop after a warning.
  • Not answering. A board is under no obligation to respond to a question during public comment, and often will not.

Sourced to sourcesourcesource

Can a student under 18 speak?

Nothing in New Jersey law stops you. The statute gives the right to any governmental or school district issue that a member of the public feels may be of concern10:4-12(a). We read the whole Act: there is no age qualifier, no residency qualifier and no parental-consent requirement anywhere in it. NJSBA’s own guide notes that students often attend and participate.source

Some districts go further and say so out loud. One district’s 0167 extends the opportunity to “employees and pupils of this district” and directs the presiding officer to alter the order of speakers so that students go first.

What the evening is actually like

Smaller than you are imagining. A typical board meeting has more empty seats than people. The board sits at a long table, the superintendent sits with them, and there is a microphone or a lectern for the public.

Find the agenda first. Most districts post one even though the law does not strictly require it.source Arrive ten minutes early, because if there is a sign-in sheet it is usually at the back of the room and it usually closes when the meeting starts. When your turn comes, say your name and your town, say your piece, thank them, and sit down.

Expect no answer. Boards frequently take comment without responding, and that is not a snub: it is how most of them run. A board may also refer a question to the superintendent to look into. Your comment is in the minutes either way.10:4-14

Asking for a resolution

This is the ask your board can actually grant. NJSBA runs a programme for exactly this purpose: it “encourages local school boards to formally state their position on these issues by approving resolutions and sending them to the governor, legislative leadership, their local legislative representatives” and others, and publishes templates in the format boards already use.source Pointing your board at that page is more persuasive than anything we could write, because it is their own association telling them this is normal.

There is no law requiring two readings before a board adopts something, and a board is not barred from taking up a matter that was not on the agenda, though most boards have their own bylaw and their own habits.source

Draft resolution for a board of education

Change this before you send it. This is a starting point for a board, not something you can adopt yourself: only the board can pass it. Fill in the district name, and expect the board attorney to rewrite the recitals, which is normal and fine. The second resolved clause is deliberate: a resolution that also reaffirms support for the instructional-time restriction is far easier for a board to vote for than one that reads as opposition to the law.

RESOLUTION REQUESTING THAT THE NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION REVISE ITS GUIDANCE ON STUDENT USE OF INTERNET-ENABLED DEVICES

WHEREAS, P.L. 2025, c. 195 directs the Commissioner of Education to develop guidelines prohibiting the non-academic use of internet-enabled devices on school grounds during the school day; and

WHEREAS, the statute does not use the terms "lunch," "study hall," or "passing time"; and

WHEREAS, the New Jersey Department of Education has construed the statute as requiring a bell-to-bell policy, and its Frequently Asked Questions state that students may not use personal internet-enabled devices during on-campus lunch, study hall, or the time between classes; and

WHEREAS, the same Frequently Asked Questions permit student use of personal internet-enabled devices on a school bus and during an off-campus open lunch period, both of which are unstructured and non-instructional; and

WHEREAS, section 2.e of P.L. 2025, c. 195 permits a board of education to adopt a policy more stringent than the Commissioner's guidelines, and contains no provision permitting a less stringent policy, so that this Board has no authority to make this change locally; and

WHEREAS, the Department's guidance directs districts to revisit and update their policies annually to reflect stakeholder feedback; and

WHEREAS, this Board has heard from students, families and staff in this district regarding the operation of the policy during non-instructional periods;

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of Education of [district name] respectfully requests that the Commissioner of Education revise the Guidance for Schools on Student Use of Internet-Enabled Devices so that on-campus lunch, study hall and passing time are treated as non-instructional time; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Board reaffirms its full support for the restriction on device use during instructional time, and will continue to implement its adopted policy in accordance with the guidelines as they stand; and

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Commissioner of Education, the members of the State Board of Education, the Senator and Assembly members representing this district, and the New Jersey School Boards Association.

Ground rules

Write your three minutesFind your district’s policy